Thanks for writing in, and for the excellent question. I’d first like to congratulate you for having what appears to be an unusually expansive empathy, in that you are trying to do right by your fiancé in terms of your mutual sex life, his issues and sensitivity around trauma, and, of course, your own feelings about all this. Obviously, this is a complex question, which accounts for the long-ish answer you’re about to get.
The first thing that comes to mind here is: There’s something not sexy about this for you; sex is a little like humor in the sense that it tickles us or it doesn’t. Your fiancé’s request to carry out what sounds like a role-play scenario doesn’t seem to hit the eros chord for you, and nothing’s more of a turn-off than forcing yourself to do something too edgy or discomforting.
Part of the uneasy factor is that the requested scenario seems to parallel your fiancé’s sexual abuse, which is still fresh for you (just having heard about it). Let me say here that what defines “healthy sexuality” could—and has—filled volumes upon volumes. It is a never-ending debate in my field. My own guidelines for “healthy” sex would mean, first and foremost, that the sex is consensual and safe for all parties. Other than that, the spectrum is infinitely broad. I know heterosexual men who like wearing stockings, and gay men who act brutish and tough in the bedroom. Working with sexuality means you’re dealing with the unconscious, and 10 different therapists would give you 10 different interpretations of what your partner’s sexual preferences are “really about.” As indicated, however, I get the impression from your letter that something about this feels uncomfortable, perhaps a bit unsafe, and I think that is at the core of what needs to be dealt with between you.
My clinical experience has shown me that a dynamic sexuality often includes a sense of experimentation, emotional expression, and spontaneity. There’s nothing at all wrong with role playing, though when the “play” part becomes rigidified, with an endlessly repeated “script,” to the point where mutual expression seems muzzled, where the sex has to be a certain way or someone will be unhappy, then it’s time to take a step back and see how things can be loosened up. Playfulness and humor, too, can be a way of masking or deflecting emotion, but if sex becomes too serious or heavy, it becomes stifling. Just as important here is the fact that what happens in the bedroom so often mirrors what is happening, emotionally and relationally, in the relationship itself. Sexuality is another spoke in the wheel of relating, not a separate wheel unto itself, though we often think of it that way. This leads me to wonder if you ever feel kept at a distance or put in a position of power in your emotional lives together.
I’m not exactly sure how dark or heavy a “flavor” we’re talking about here, though it sounds like (I’m assuming) you would be in the “perpetrator” role; if I assume that these scenarios have a sadomasochistic tinge, perhaps your fiancé is asking you to take the “S” role in a way you’d rather not. I’m imagining it might be painful to play a role in which you are hurting your beloved in a way parallel to earlier, horrifying experiences.
Whether these scenarios are healthy for a person to enact really depends on context and their psychological history (and is a source of intense debate among therapists). I believe that, for some people, allowing scenarios derived from trauma to emerge in a sexual context might actually give a person control and power over a previously painful narrative; they are able to “make use” of the trauma in a way they can control and derive pleasure from, a way of telling their story their own way, which now offers pleasure and not just pain. Ironically, allowing trauma memories to mingle with consciousness, even under the cloak of sexual fantasy, is a step forward for some who have completely dissociated or disconnected from such awful memories. For other people, such enactments can take on a compulsive flavor, where satisfaction can be found only by acting out one’s feelings and experiences this way, which inevitably makes their actual sexual partners feel distant and/or controlled. Where one draws the line between playful expression of one’s sensibilities and a darker, more destructive and harmful behavior is up for debate and highly dependent on specifics.
I think the only way to resolve this, since it so directly involves so many facets of your relationship, is to handle it relationally—that is, with your fiancé. This isn’t something you can figure out on your own. Dialogue is essential. I’d first decide what you are and aren’t willing to try in bed. Would you be up for trying a “light” version of his scenario, or exploring it, to see if there are aspects of it that can be treated as a kind of game, where play and spontaneity are included? Could it be seen as a kind of foreplay, where (again, not knowing the specifics) you could employ a little spanking or tying up or a scenario that is sexy to both of you and not too edgy or overwhelming? Or is it all just a big turn-off and not your “thing” at all?
I’d then sit down and relate as honestly as you can. You obviously care about him a great deal, want to please him but have concerns about his request. I’d try to stick to your own feelings. Saying, “I’m not sure this is a good way to resolve your issues” sounds a little therapisty; you might try saying, “The idea of this makes me (uneasy, uncomfortable, etc.).” Can a compromise be reached? Can the two of you let your sexual imaginations come up with something you both find desirable?
Try not to think too hard about what will help your fiancé resolve his trauma. Frankly, just having an open conversation wherein you are honest about your feelings, while empathic toward his, will likely be a healing experience for both of you. I honestly do not think any partner’s job is to help the other resolve any issues; that’s what therapists are for. Honest relating and working through things respectfully and lovingly is itself healing. You can support him in his therapy work, of course, but you, too, are on a journey, and one person’s trauma does not “cancel out” the other’s desires or wishes to feel heard, respected, and safe—sexually and otherwise.
Thanks again for writing. Hope that helped.
Darren
The preceding article was solely written by the author named above. Any views and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by GoodTherapy.org.