Is It Friendship If You Have Nothing in Common Anymore?
Dear Friend Until the End,
Thanks for your question. I guess the simple and perhaps even smart-alecky answer would be, “Don’t talk about politics and stick to sports!” I have very good friends who disagree with me politically and we are so passionate about our respective views that we simply agree to disagree. With others, I find it a little easier to have a more moderately tempered exchange; for example, I have a college buddy on Facebook who has drifted to the opposite end of the spectrum as me, but he has a sense of humor and pokes fun at my “side” and we have a good-natured sparring relationship about it. I could not do that with everyone.
But on a broader and philosophical level, your question points to a very psychologically significant phenomenon—related to change and, perhaps, loss.
The sometimes jarring fact of the matter is people change. There are friends from my past, as I sit here in middle age, whom I would no longer recognize. Some I am happy to stay in touch with via Facebook, and some I just can’t find common ground with anymore. A lot of this is about the present: the ongoing, indestructible present moment, which creates a context around what remains in common today. And other than a shared past, there are some with whom we just don’t share much in common anymore. Sometimes a new place—geographically, emotionally—can change a person, which changes his or her relationships. Sounds like your friend has changed for reasons that, I’m guessing, have little to do with you, but do affect the friendship.
We all exist in a particular context, often fleeting, ever shifting. (This would be related to what Buddhists call “groundlessness.”) In the case of your friend, you and he shared some very intense experiences in a common setting, but obviously things have changed in more complicated ways than can be assessed by the human eye. It sounds to me like you would have to make an adjustment to “fit” this new situation by listening to the “jibber jabber” of your friend’s politics. Perhaps these politics have become important to him for some reason that blocks more friendly relating. Could you ask him to drop this as a topic? Or is life too short to even bother at this point?
I was curious about the notion of an “obligation” to him, and I think that warrants further investigation. Why “obligation”? What are the risks of not following this new “requirement”? My sense is that not staying obligated might bring with it a loss of a kind that could be symbolic for you: for example, this friend was like a brother, and losing him might be related to experiencing a brotherly loss of a kind. Maybe you feel you’ve lost too many “friends” lately. Is there a loneliness losing him might touch on? Or perhaps there are people in your life like him, and for some reason you feel like you “owe” it to them to stay uncomfortable listening to opinions that seriously clash with yours. There is something abrasive about feeling “forced” to listen to political opinions that don’t jibe with yours; it sounds as if it might be more of a monologue than a conversation. “Fun for one,” as a friend likes to say. It does you no good to force yourself in such situations. I suppose you could try to “understand” his positions, if you’re interested, but that’s a lot of work on your part, and it may or may not be worth it.
More importantly, why hold on to this particular friendship if it’s no longer fun or friendly? It sounds like your college pal now wants your audience as more than a friend, from what you’ve said. Assuming he’s going to cling to his political points of view, what purpose does it serve by pretending a friendship is there that has changed or even faded away? I get a sad feeling while writing this, since people do come in and then out of our lives in a way that can spark specific feelings in us, depending on who we are and how we process these experiences.
In short, see if getting politics out of the equation helps, or if by continuing this friendship you are staving off inevitable feelings of loss that, unfortunately, are as difficult in life as connections are rewarding. You seem like a nice, considerate fellow, and I’m hoping there are people in your life whom you can spend more time with, rather than forcing a situation that no longer suits your particular context. Thank you for writing!
Best wishes,
Darren
- 12 comments
- Leave a Comment
Tate
February 27th, 2015 at 1:04 PMWe all live and learn and grow, sometimes apart for sure. That doesn’t mean you have to be unkind, but it is good to know that there are probably other people out there that you would rather spend your time with.
Anonymous
August 4th, 2016 at 12:32 AMI am a middle aged woman, never married, no children. I have had my ups and downs in life. Some of my best friends have passed away. Others have such a different lifestyle from me that it is hardly even possible to meet up with them. I work freelance and am basically a night owl. A few of my 9-5 friends keep such different hours than I do that is virtually impossible to meet with them. One friend works every weekend. She finally had a free weekend and wanted to do something social. Just so happens that I need to take care of some important business and personal matters that weekend. I know this person is disappointed, but I must take care of myself first.
I had another friend for many years. She was very focused on getting married. That was great. However she had no time for me. No problem. Fast forward 10 years. We have been completely out of touch. She has 2 kids and lives in a suburb about 100 miles from me. We really have little in common any more, even though we were childhood friends.
Sometimes we change our lifestyle so much that our old friends really do not match up with us anymore.
Friends don’t grow on trees. The ones I find I can remain friends with are flexible and know that we have different work hours, etc. They do not expect me to abandon the activities I must do in order to take care of my life’s affairs in order to get together with them. I recognize their individuality as they recognize mine. There is a fundamental connection and mutual respect.
Just for example, I sometimes like to attend midnight mass on Christmas Eve – one if the few times I attend Catholic mass. This past Christmas my friend asked me to attend mass at her church – Presbyterian – at 11 pm. I told her I was planning to attend mass in my own church at midnight and could meet her afterwards. She said it was too late to meet her and could not understand why I did not want to attend her church. Knowing that she does not like to attend mass anywhere other than her own church I thanked her and wished her a Happy Christmas. She said it would be too late to meet her after midnight mass, even though she was off Christmas Day and had no other plans. So we rarely see one another. She has very particular things she likes to do as do I.
She refuses to stay out later than she likes so expects I should forgo activities I find important (go to the gym, take care of my home and business) to see her. As time has gone by, we see less and less of one another. While I am sorry not to see her very often, I respect her need to take care of her own “business” and would never expect her to do otherwise. She makes critical remarks and is hurt that I do not like to do the things she does. That is really the root of the problem – her lack of understanding that our lifestyles are different even though we care for one another. Sometimes it is difficult to remain friends with longtime acquaintances, even though they are good people.Bret
February 28th, 2015 at 10:27 AMI would love to know why it seems like there is a need to hold onto something that is not there anymore I am just curious about that, why, if you think that the two of you have grown apart, you aren’t really okay with that and willing to let that friendship go.
Leave a Comment
By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of GoodTherapy.org's Terms and Conditions of Use.